Book Review: Terry Pratchett’s “Nation”
I actually had this sitting around for ages – at least since Christmas, and you know, it might even have been the previous Christmas – and just recently got to reading it.
I’ve always liked Terry Pratchett, but this book is a bit of a departure for me; it’s not a Discworld book, and despite the back-cover blurb advertising “Terry Pratchett’s inimitable comic satire”, it’s not really a funny book, either. There are jokes, and it has its moments, but it’s not a comedy.
“Nation” is set in a sort of alternative-history parallel-universe, in the equivalent of the Pacific Ocean in the equivalent of the nineteenth century. It’s about a boy named Mau; one of the few survivors of a tidal wave which wipes out the primitive island civilisation he knows as “The Nation”.
As Mau tries to come to terms with what has happened, he begins to question everything around him… and why the gods brought this upon him.
In this way, “Nation” becomes something like Terry Pratchett’s fictional version of “The God Delusion”. Mau encounters and dismisses many of the common arguments in religious apologetics; when he’s told that the gods have smiled on him in allowing him to live, he responds: that just means they let everyone else die. And there are some nice Pratchett-isms in there, like “’It’s God’s Will’ is just grown-up-speak for ‘Because’”.
There are examples of how people project their expectations onto things they don’t understand; people assigning divinity to technology.
It’s also about our culture and society and the things we take for granted about our customs and our insecurities.
It’s a good book in many ways, but I felt I was reading a sort of children’s manual for skepticism – no bad thing in itself, but not what I was expecting, and I’m not sure I’d recommend it too heavily to anyone. It’s the sort of book you’d buy a young person to encourage critical thinking, and in that role it’s probably brilliant.